Well,
I made it. I managed to sit through eight and a half hours of this mess of a
show. Now, let me start off by making a few things clear. One, I am a huge fan
of the first season of the show. I am not alone in this opinion, the majority
of people proclaim it to be one of the best seasons of television in recent
memory. I would go as far as to argue that the first season of True Detective
was among the best programs we have been offered on the small screen.
Everything from the set design to the subtle yet haunting score was perfectly
implemented and utilized in the first season. The first season also has to give
thanks to the acting talents of Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson, who
were not only the selling point of the trailer of this show, but held up the
promise their resumes showed the potential for. Had this show not had those two
actors starring in it, I can honestly say that I would have never tried this
show, at least on its opening night. The first season of True Detective did
something very well that this season did not, that was remain balanced. For
instance, were it not for Marty Hart, the audience would have certainly grown
tired of Rust Cohle's creepy and dark monologues as there would be no contrast
to what he was saying. It would have been overwhelming dark, and it would have
taken most of the life out of the show. Since we had Marty Hart, as well as his
wife and the detectives interviewing Rust for the majority of the season, it
gave a perfect balance to Rust's philosophy. The problem that the second season
has, is that there is no balance. It would be like taking Marty out of all of
the car scenes from the first season, and replacing it with McConaughey driving
in an empty car talking about how time is a flat circle, and after all we are
nothing but farts in the wind or some other dark monologue. It would not have
been enjoyable, it would have been a lifeless and boring scene. Sadly, this is
basically how the second season goes. Instead of being a show with extremely
pessimistic dark moments contrasted with the struggles of married family life
it gives us a season of characters that basically tell us life sucks and no one
ever gets what they want.
For
me, the most memorable aspect of the first season was how much it felt like one
long film. All the episodes ran together, and if you binge watch the
entire season (as I have done several times) it works perfectly as a long film.
The directing of Cary Fukunaga perfectly fits Pizzolatto's noir pulp scripts.
There have been a number of articles speculating for months that Fukunaga and
Pizzolatto had some kind of feud that made him turn down the job of directing
the second season. He remained as an executive producer, but only he knows how
much he actually contributed to the season. For me, I think that the biggest
problem this show has is its writer. Now I don't want to be just another person
talking about how he is an ego maniac who is unwilling to work with anyone
unless they want to listen to him and give him ultimate control over the
project. I have read two of his works outside of his television writing. I read
his book Galveston, and one of his short stories. I also have seen the first
three seasons of The Killing, of which he wrote a handful of episodes during
the first season. I watched him give a speech/Q&A to a panel of students on
YouTube where he complained about the writers’ room on the show and complained
that it just didn't work for him. Now, when I watched this the first time I had
only experienced the first season of True Detective, and so I believed
that maybe he just wasn't someone who could write in a crowd, I was fully
confident in his writing considering the strength and power his creative talent
had on the first season. However, after reading his novel, a short story and
the second season of the show where he again penned all eight episodes
unassisted I have some serious doubts about his capabilities as a writer. I am
not saying he cannot write, or that he is a bad writer, I am simply saying that
he doesn't have the ability to write a show entirely on his own that can
deliver like the first season did. I feel strongly that it was a one hit
wonder. In his novel Galveston, he crafted two very dynamic and deep characters
that helped me fly through the novel in a few days. The problem with the novel
was the plot, and the main problem with his writing in general is his plot
development. In the novel the plot seemed to cut corners and intense moments
happened with little explanation or build up. In both the show and his novel,
the intense moments are well done and keep you on the edge of your seat, the
problem is you don't know entirely why you are on the edge of your seat because
nothing is explained and the most minute of details end up being the key to
unlocking the overly complex plot devices in the show. I think Nic wrote this
season as kind of a middle finger to his critics. At the end of the season, the
only characters left standing are female. Now, as you may or may not know, Nic
was heavily criticized for his lack of strong female characters during the
first season. I think this may have been fuelled by his abnormal interest in
the prostitution and stripper industry. Everything I have read or watched from
this guy always includes strippers, prostitution or a sex ring. So it’s not
hard to see why he was criticized the way that he was. Now, having the females
emerge at the end was way too cheesy and cliché for me. It felt like I was
watching a weird terminator/Ghost rip off home movie by the end. I
was waiting for Rachel McAdams to look at the camera and say that there is
a storm coming and that her baby was going to lead the resistance against
Skynet. It was such a terrible ending to a terrible show, and I place all the
blame on Nic Pizzolatto.
This season we had a slew of directors
helm each episode. We were promised a more action oriented season with a faster
pace. This could not have been farther from the truth. Aside from a
one big shoot out sequence, all of the few action moments in the show were
brought about in contrived ways that you could not understand why they were
happening unless you had been taking notes like Rust did during the first
season. As for the fast pace, honestly, that's the most laughable thing now
looking back on the season we got. Episodes got worse and worse as the
season went on, aside from episode 6 and the first half of episode 7 this
season for me was a complete joke. I am not going to go into the plot since it
is a mess, but if you can connect all the dots and follow what is happening in
this show
then you deserve a gold star. The entire season was boring. The characters
aside from Ray Velcoro were terribly developed and made absolutely no sense.
The acting this season also took a step backward compared to last season. A
notable exception was Colin Farrell, he gave a masterful performance, although
his acting in my opinion declined as the season went on, but then again
everything about this show kind of slipped away as time went on. Rachel McAdams
and Taylor Kitsch did an admirable job considering the contrived characters
they had to play. Vince Vaughn's acting was stiff and wooden throughout most of
the season, in the later episodes it felt that he had grown a accustomed to his
character more and felt more at home, although it wasn't enough to save his mob
boss character whose most memorable back story for me was his lack of success
at growing avocado trees. On a side note, Nic's writing this year seemed to
heavily stand on the shoulders of older Noir and pulp films.
From Frank's worry
that he was still in the basement from his past that seemed eerily reminiscent
of Tim Robbins worry in Mystic River, to the moment when Frank looked back at
his dead body in a Patrick Swayze Demi Moore Ghost rip off moment in some
desert. Considering the accusations of his plagiarizing of Rust's dialogue in
the first season, I don't understand his motivations to use plot devices that
had been used before in much more elaborate ways. Lastly, while we are loosely still talking about actors, let us mention the
weakest actor I have ever seen on an HBO television program, Kelly Reilly. From
her lack of emotion in her face to the monotone delivery of her lines, her
character was the lowest of lows for me on this show. Every time her and her
wooden husband who couldn't get wood talked I never believed that they were in love, and
in the final episodes I often laughed out loud watching the two of them try to
act like a loving pair, it was pathetic. As for the background and supporting
characters, none of them stood out in a good or bad way. They were just there.
Unlike the first season where we had a wealth of amazing background and
supporting characters who contributed amazing one liners and sharp dialogue,
they were just like the general store in an old western movie. Neither in place
or out of place, simply there.
Let’s conclude what I thought about this
show, I have rambled on far too long. Simply put, the writing this year was
abominable. Aside from a few good comebacks the dialogue was terrible, and the
plot was impossible to understand for the majority of the audience, myself
included. The acting aside from Colin Farrell ranged from good, to okay, to
terrible. The directing and cinematography are basically god awful this time
around. If you cut out every highway shot we got this year you could easily cut
ten to fifteen minutes off the runtime of this show. The fact of the matter is
this, the second season tried, and it tried hard, but it failed. Aside from the
higher ratings, critically speaking, it was a disaster. It’s time for Nic, and
the rest of the staff behind this show to pick themselves up, dust themselves
off and move forward. However, there is one thing I hope above all else happens
for the next season. I hope that HBO forces Nic Pizzolatto into working
with a writers room, or at least having a few experienced novelist/editors read
over his scripts and better them, or at least dumb them down a bit so as to not
sacrifice the audiences enjoyment so that he can stroke his ego some more. I
can pray that Cary Fukunaga comes back as the director of the third season, but
I feel that is probably very unlikely from happening. If I had to rate this
season, I would give it a 4.5/10, it had a few good moments, and a good
shootout, but I would not go out of my way to watch this just for those few
moments. I am not planning on purchasing this season on Blu Ray as I did the
first, simply because nothing about this season was memorable and I would gain
nothing from watching it again except for a deeper understanding into the
Freudian mind of Pizzolatto and the mess of a plot he wrote for this season.
Heres to hoping the third season of the show returns to greatness.








































