Friday, August 8, 2014

No Country for Old Men - Novel Review

I finished reading No Country for Old Men a couple of hours ago. I thought about the book alot since finishing it and thought it would only do me justice to express my thoughts in a review. I hope this review entertains and conveys how I felt about the book so that you can decide whether or not you would want to read this novel.

The novel follows three main characters, a sheriff trying to understand what makes man go wrong, a veteran who is trying to be a good guy, and a pure villain. These three characters are followed separately for most of this book, never having actual interaction with eachother for a the majority of the story. This is an on the run story as well, the main plot being that Moss, the veteran good guy, has found a drug deal gone wrong, and upon finding this he discovers two million dollars in a satchel. From here he is being hunted, and he realizes this not long after finding it. For the most part, this story drives the plot at a fast rate, and keeps the reader completely enticed with the work. For me, it worked well for the most part, I began this novel just wanting to read a few pages and set it down, I had no intention of finishing this book, I just wanted a taste. I ended up reading the entire novel in a little under two days, which is extremely fast for me to read a book. The font in my copy of the book was rather large, as was the spacing between the dialogue, but rest assured I will talk alot about the writing of this novel when I get there, for now I want to delve into the plot of this work. The story moves very well, the only problem being the character of the sheriff. This character's scenes and dialogue throughout the book seemed to drag for me, every time I had to read this character's perspective I felt somewhat bored, and not as inside the story as the other two character's point of view. What I mean is that, when the other two characters were in the novel, it felt as if we were there with him, however when we are with the sheriff it feels like we are sitting on Santa's lap listening to him dryly recite all of his old man wisdom. I enjoy his wisdom throughout the novel, there were many powerful quotes and passages. Though, most of them come within the last forty pages of the novel which are entirely from his perspective. Aside from this part of the novel, the sheriff character for me was not overly enjoyable, at least as compared to the amazing other two character's. The main character of Moss was a fantastic character, he had a wisdom to him that wasn't overpowering and he had the most amazing sarcastic attitude I had ever read in a book. I loved this character, everything from his thoughts, to his attitude to how he viewed the rolling hills of the desert and the sheets of a motel room. This character was probably my favourite from any book, other then Michael Noonan from Bag of Bones. The final main character in this novel is Anton Chigurh, another amazing character. This character is hand in hand with Moss for my all time favourite fiction character. He is scary and has an interesting outlook on the world. His dialogue was amazing in this novel. Every scene with this man was almost as if he was controlling fate, but he never did, he just knew the likelihood and inevitability chance has. I really enjoyed this character too, I am not sure which is my favourite in this novel, but both are amazing to read, and were the main reason I flew through this novel. The plot wraps itself up in a very artistic, and dramatic way. I assure you that once you finish this novel and look back on the journey you had with it, you will truly admire the story and every theme that is packed inside this book. The book flows at an almost perfect pace, only slowing at points when the sheriff appears in the first half of the book. However, I am not certain the pace of the novel did this, however it was my straining while reading these parts of the book. There are numerous occasions throughout this book that your heart will race from the suspense the novel develops. Another thing I want to say is that the scenery and setting elaborated on and discovered throughout this novel is amazing. From the motel rooms to the desert it is all very beautiful, it is helped by the mass amount of description Cormac uses while describing the setting of the story in a very beautiful and rustic way. If I rated the plot and experience I had reading this novel, I would rate it a 9/10, the only reason I give it a 9 instead of 10 is the writing style of Cormac McCarthy, which I will elaborate on next.

This novel is amazing, however the author does something strange, and I am not calling it unique, I am almost wanting to call it arrogant, or maybe ignorant for the lack of respect for his reader. I understand that he wrote this novel, somewhat like how Stephen King writes and it feels like the story is being presented like a real life account, using things like "yessir" and "settin". However, Cormac began to annoy me with his writing at points using the words I just stated above, as well as "yonder" far too many times throughout this novel. I have heard people call his work poetic, and fantastic, but for me its just not appealing in that fashion. I enjoyed his writing, and really wanted to love it as the film adaptation is my favourite film ever made. However, the writing really frustrated me. For instance, I used to hate Shakespeare's work as he didn't abide by the rules of the english language, however, through reading a translate "No Fear Shakespeare" edition of his work, I was able to enjoy his amazing stories, characters and other such literary skills. I feel the same way towards Cormac, I loved his characters for the most part, loved the plot and every such following literary structure within this novel. However, his writing style really angered me and took me out of the novel at points. I wish he would do simple things such as quotations, or proper sentences, but he simply doesn't. This led to me becoming confused and lost in the dialogue at points being unable to interpret which character was thinking or talking. To him I am sure there is no problem with this, but for the readers around the world, I am certain everyone has become lost at some point or another while reading his work due to his lack of proper structuring in his novel.  This is what led me to giving my rating above, and for my basic writing category of critique, I give Cormac a lackluster 5.5/10. This book is by no means poorly written, and Cormac McCarthy is not a bad author, he is simply a little confusing for me to follow, and for that I gave him this rating.

To wrap things up, let me say that this novel is a fantastic piece of literature, and I am assured that it will be a long living classic in libraries and bookstores for many decades to come. The only problem with this novel is the author's writing, if you are able to understand his obscured style you will have no problem flying through this amazing plot filled with many fantastic scenarios, characters, suspense moments all happening at the perfect pace. In conclusion, all things on top, I rate this novel a 9/10. I implore you to read this novel, the writing does hinder the enjoyment value of the book, however, with a little work done, this book is something very enjoyable as well as something that will possibly change your outlook on regret and growing old in a young man's world.

Regards, Matthew Spence

No comments:

Post a Comment

Followers

Search This Blog

My Top Twenty Favorite TV Shows

  • 1. Breaking Bad
  • 2. House MD
  • 3. Six Feet Under
  • 4. The Twilight Zone
  • 5. House of Cards
  • 6. Hannibal
  • 7. The Killing
  • 8. True Detective
  • 9. Mad Men
  • 10. Boardwalk Empire
  • 11. The Sopranos
  • 12. Hell on Wheels
  • 13. American Horror Story
  • 14. Dexter
  • 15. Bates Motel
  • 16. Seinfeld
  • 17. The X Files
  • 18. Siberia
  • 19. The Following
  • 20. Under the Dome